A few months ago, my husband and I drove to Estes Park, Colorado, for a weekend camping trip. We live near Dallas, so the drive is a bit of a hike. It was a great trip. We’d gone to Estes Park on our first ever trip together eight years ago, so it’s sort of near and dear to us.
But I digress. On the long twelve-hour drive back to Dallas, we commenced a conversation, the ultimate effects of which I only really experienced this past week. Allow me to explain. We were talking about our vague, naive, wide-eyed plans for the future and somehow came to the decision that I should continue my education and pursue a Ph.D. in English. But it would only be worth it if I could pursue said Ph.D. at one of the ivy-bedecked Holy Trinity institutions: Harvard, Princeton, or Yale. Thus began my downward spiral into unspeakable depression, self-loathing, and hopelessness, the likes of which few have ever known.
OK, I’m exaggerating. But suffice to say, the past six months have sucked, like, a lot.
I had no idea what I was getting myself into. Well, I had an idea, I just didn’t have the right idea, evidently. My perilous journey toward Ivy League Rejection was comprised of the following: taking and achieving high scores on (99th percentile) the GRE and the (f*%&ing impossible) GRE Subject Test in Literature; securing recommendations from professors with whom I haven’t spoken in years; and writing both a ground-breaking 25-page scholarly paper and a brilliant, gut-wrenching, convincing personal statement. These are the things that the applications TELL you are required. But don’t be fooled. There are a number of things that are required that they DON’T tell you about. First, you should be on a first-name basis with members of the faculty at the Ivy to which you are applying. Second, you should have a stack of very dull and obtuse published works under your belt. And third, your father should be a Kennedy. Ok, not really, but I will divulge that Harvard’s financial aid “application” is little more than a series of questions about who you’re related to. Specifically, is your surname Baxendale, Downer, Hudson, or Thayer? Are you a descendant of a member of the class of 1889 or 1902? Incestuous bastards.
Let me preface the details of this exercise in masochism by saying that I had no delusions of actually being accepted to one of these schools. Sure, a secret, infinitesimal part of me dared to dream of what it might be like to stroll through Harvard Yard on a crisp October morning, the smell of coffee, cash, and unwarranted success wafting through the invigorating air. But I also calculated my odds of getting in at about one in 50 — at best. So I let the dejection settle in my gut, even while I was working furiously to study, write, and charm my way into their exclusive little club.
Here’s how it all went down. I studied as best I could for the Subject Test in Literature. It is an accutely cruel exam. They can literally ask you anything about any piece of literature ever writtern. Ever. I scored in the 55th percentile and was surprised I did even that well. And now I know more than I ever wanted to about Shakespeare and Homer and all the writers I made a point of avoiding in undergrad. Next stop: the GRE. I really did study hard for this one. I memorized around 500 vocabulary words with obsequious attentiveness! Alas, my verbal score was in the 91st percentile — nothing to sneeze at, but I needed to be in the 99th. I wept when I got the results.
As for my writing sample, each of the three schools conveniently requested a different page requirement: 25 for Princeton, 15-20 for Harvard, and 10-15 for Yale. So I wrote a 25-page paper for Princeton and then pared it down for the other two. The topic was supposed to be in the area you wished to study for your Ph.D. I’m interested in creative non-fiction, so I chose to write about Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood. The title of the resulting masterpiece was “Anatomy of the Nonfiction Novel: An Examination of Plot Structure and the Truth as Art in Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood.” I was pretty proud of it, all said and done, but I knew deep down that it wasn’t convoluted enough to wow the admissions committees.
Then there were the recommendations. I mean, who doesn’t love groveling to almost-strangers and requesting significant favors? Fortunately, I was able to reestablish contact with some of my grad school professors. They were all extremely kind and obliging, but in the same breath advised me to consider NYU, or a state school, or getting a few things published. I couldn’t have agreed with them more, but that wasn’t my dream. “The Ivies. THE IVIES!” my heart cried thunderously. OK, I’m exaggerating again, but I really did feel that the best schools were the only ones that were worth it. And that sentiment was compounded by this nagging urge I’ve felt of late to do something important with my life before I turn 30.
Last of all came the statement of interest, a well- but hastily-written diatribe in which I painted myself as a self-made girl for whom acceptance would change the course of future generations of Stephanies. Lost in a haze of doubt and resignation, it was really the best I could do.
And then, two days after Christmas, it was done. After about a thousand dollars, a few dozen glasses of wine, and bucket or so of tears, I submitted all three applications. My husband and I jetted off to Spain and France for New Year’s, so I didn’t have much time to think about everything right away. But when we got back, it was always, at the very least, lurking in the back of my mind. Most of me was dreading the inevitable rejections, but part of me was hoping for that thick, satisfying envelope to show up in the mail box one day, and I knew that I wouldn’t even open it, I’d just rush out to pick up a bottle of Veuve Clicquot and let the celebrations begin.
Princeton came first. It showed up in an email with a benign but unpromising subject line: “Princeton University Graduate Admission Decision.” Ah yes. I see. Though there are many excellent applicants who apply each year (though they made a point of not implying that I was among said applicants), there are only a small number of spaces available (and you’re not getting one of them, sucker!). Great. I spent the day in a depression deeper than what I’d anticipated, that kind of sadness that you can feel all the way into your toes.
Yale came about two weeks later, also by email: “Yale University Graduate School Application Decision.” They too had received many applications from excellent candidates (again, of whom they did not suggest I was one) but had a limited number of spaces available. This one hurt less for some reason. Now I was just waiting for the big H.
I guess they have a bigger postage budget, or they just get a kick out of inflicting that singular brand of pain that only a pathetic, flacid, unbearably flat envelope bearing their crimson seal can command. I received this one just this past Saturday. I really hadn’t expected to get in, especially after Harvard’s lesser brothers had already denied me. But it really hit me hard. A big. Fat. No. After opening, reading, and quickly discarding the letter, I went to my room, sat down in my closet, and cried for about 20 minutes. Then I thought I should pull myself up off the ground and grow a pair. But I only made it to the living room where I crumpled onto the carpet again and cried for another hour or so. I didn’t even feel like drinking. I just wanted to sit and be sad.
The thing is, it’s not just Harvard. Or Princeton or Yale. It was everything that went with it. I could finally get out of Texas. I would be doing something huge and important. I would have a more definite career path. In short, I could be proud of myself.
And that’s really all I have to say about it right now. It’s difficult not to feel like the whole endeavor was a huge waste of time, energy, and money. I don’t have a tidy summation of the experience or some trite, bullshitty moral I’ve taken away from it all. It was an ego-crushing experience of epic proportions and I don’t quite see the point of it. Not that I think everything in life has to have a point. I gave it a shot and it didn’t work out, and frankly, it sucks. And no, I don’t necessarily feel like there’s something better waiting for me. Let’s call a spade a spade — what could be better than Harvard? Well, I’d like to think that I’m better than Harvard, but so far, I’m clearly not. So I guess that’s something to work toward.